Everyone obsesses over Black Friday and Cyber Monday — but only 17% of total holiday spend actually happens during the Cyber Five. The other 83% is sitting in the weeks before and after, and most brands pull back right when they should be leaning in. Brett brings in OMG Commerce’s Google, retention, and Amazon leads to break down exactly what to do in-game and post-game: where to watch your ad spend drift, which emails actually drive a second wave of sales, and why Amazon’s own reporting might be hiding your biggest wins.
Inside the episode:
- Why Black Friday posts the highest ROAS of the Cyber Five — and why Cyber Monday is actually the day to hold your budget back
- The Performance Max “drift” that can quietly shift your spend into the wrong channels during your biggest week
- A 4-step post-peak email/SMS sequence (think behind-the-scenes content and package inserts) that creates a second sales wave after the orders ship
- Why 20% of a brand’s SKUs drive 67% of its sales — and what that means for your inventory and coupon decisions mid-sale
- The “boxing day” window (Dec 26–31) where click costs crater and ROAS spikes — and how to build a promo plan around it
- Why Amazon’s own reporting makes it nearly impossible to see what actually worked on Cyber Five, and the simple daily habit that fixes it
—
Sponsored by OMG Commerce - go to https://www.omgcommerce.com/contact and request your FREE strategy session today!
—
Chapters:
[0:00] Introduction: The 83% Opportunity Outside the Cyber Five
[1:42] Google In-Game: Watching for Performance Max Channel Drift
[3:12] Budget Management: Black Friday vs. Cyber Monday Returns
[4:37] Spend Breakdown: Protecting Margin Through the Cyber Days
[6:59] Email & SMS In-Game: Personalized FOMO and Send Frequency
[10:34] Amazon In-Game: Inventory Surprises and Protecting Profitability
[13:11] Google Post-Game: The 40% After Cyber Monday and Boxing Day
[15:47] The Final Push: YouTube, Demand Gen, and Shipping Deadlines
[18:49] Email & SMS Post-Game: BTS Photos, Package Inserts, and Last Offers
[23:10] Amazon Post-Game: Pull Your Data Before You Forget
[26:34] Gift Cards and Post-Christmas Spend: Amazon Ad Strategy
[31:48] Final Tips: Write Your Projections Before Peak Season
—
Connect With Brett:
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/thebrettcurry/
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCQmbMwBW8LYDfFAqNqlgTGw
Website: https://www.omgcommerce.com/
Request a Free Strategy Session: https://www.omgcommerce.com/contact
Past guests on eCommerce Evolution include Ezra Firestone, Steve Chou, Drew Sanocki, Jacques Spitzer, Jeremy Horowitz, Ryan Moran, Sean Frank, Andrew Youderian, Ryan McKenzie, Joseph Wilkins, Cody Wittick, Miki Agrawal, Justin Brooke, Nish Samantray, Kurt Elster, John Parkes, Chris Mercer, Rabah Rahil, Bear Handlon, JC Hite, Frederick Vallaeys, Preston Rutherford, Anthony Mink, Bill D'Allessandro, Stephane Colleu, Jeff Oxford, Bryan Porter and more
Transcript:
Brett Curry (00:12):
Welcome back to another edition of the eCommerce Evolution Podcast. Today is part two in our peak holiday two-part series. Today we're talking about in it, in-game, and post-game for the Cyber five, the Cyber 10, the Turkey 12, whatever you want to call it. So what are we doing in game to maximize our results? And then what are we doing after that? Because here's a really interesting stat. Bill's going to talk more about this in a minute. Just saw this on the operator's pod as they were talking about holiday. Only 17% of total holiday consumer spend happens in the Cyber five. Only 17%. It's a lot. It's billions of dollars, but that means 83% happens outside of the Cyber five. And so thinking about what you do during, but also after, very critical. A couple of the biggest shopping days of the year, depending on category and things like that, happen after the Cyber Five.
Brett Curry (01:14):
And so with that, once again with me, I've got Bill Cover, Google Director at OMG Commerce, Nick Flint, retention director at OMG Commerce, and Trenton Bodenbach. He's an Amazon growth strategist and a growth rep. So he's going to be walking through Amazon tactics. Start with you first, Bill, on the Google side. What are we thinking about during the peak holiday? So Cyber five, Cyber 10, Turkey 12, whatever, what are we doing in game?
Bill Cover (01:42):
Yeah, absolutely. So when it comes to Google, I have some proprietary stats here which are pretty closely aligned to your stats. So we've noticed on the revenue side that 21% of revenue occurs within the Cyber five during Q4, 21% of Q4 revenue.
Brett Curry (02:03):
Pulling all OMG client data from last year, this is the revenue number. Yeah, it's great.
Bill Cover (02:07):
You got it. You got it. Yep. And then we're talking back half as well. So 40% of Q4 data occurs after Cyber Monday. So the back half is pretty important. When it comes to things to look for, so I'm just going to go right to one of my deep cuts. So Performance Max has a tendency to kind of wave in and out of different channels. And so you want to watch that because it can drift too far into one channel.
Brett Curry (02:39):
Seven channels in one campaign and it may be great in one and suck at the other and sometimes you don't know what it's doing, so you dig.
Bill Cover (02:46):
Yep, exactly. It could go all the way into YouTube. It could go all the way into Gmail. It runs Gmail ads, so you got to watch that. So we watch for that sort of drift and make sure that we're getting the right mix in order to get performance.
Brett Curry (03:01):
Because ideally you want search and shopping primarily, right? And this is the time for shopping to shine. But yeah, PMAX starts to drift because it wants to spend the budget, that's when you want to adjust.
Bill Cover (03:12):
Yep, exactly. Going a little bit higher level to just Google ads, budget management in general. So we've seen that the highest return in our own data is on Black Friday cyber... Or sorry, you always want to say Black Friday Cyber Money. It's on Black Friday is the highest return. So the highest ROAS last year was on Black Friday. Second highest was actually the Thursday before. So Thanksgiving or Turkey Day was the second highest ROAS. And that was very, very close. I mean, hardly any difference to Saturday and Sunday, right? So Thanksgiving, Saturday, Sunday, very similar ROAS. Monday is the one to watch out for. Monday ROAS was the lowest. And so we have a tendency sometimes to want to go big. Let's capitalize on this final day of the Cyber five, hold back on that. And it's possible as well that maybe some of that is advertising that's going on on Monday and then the sale occurs on Amazon.
Bill Cover (04:20):
That's certainly possible that it's just not being attributed to the ads and that it's happening. It's just somewhere else. But hold back on those Monday budgets. Don't go too hot on Monday. Keep that money in the bank. Don't make the ad platforms too rich.
Brett Curry (04:37):
Yeah, I love that. I love that. I'm going to show this visual really quickly here. I think this is kind of helpful as we look at the way spend is broken down. And I talked about this a little bit on part one of the podcast where in this October time period, this yellow here, yellow and the purple, that's demand gen and YouTube and almost all of that is YouTube, just different campaign types. It's like 40%, 40% of total budget. And then you got PMAX here shopping and search as percentages. As we get into early November, we're seeing search increase, we're seeing Pmax increase, we're seeing YouTube decrease. The week leading up to Cyber five, even more dramatic. And then week of, yeah, we're leaning heavily into search shopping and PMAX, that's 80% of our budget during that window. And it's super, super important. That is when we're closing deals.
Brett Curry (05:38):
And to your point, Bill, you got to look at where's ROAS the highest? And my argument would be if we start to see what likely happens, and this is something that Google will want to do, Meta will want to do for you as well. They're seeing all kinds of activity. They see you got a sale, they see there's traffic, they see there's buying intent. They're going to recommend a ton of spend on Cyber Monday. Now Cyber Monday is a great day. For some of our brands, that is a bigger sales day than even Black Friday. Black Friday wins across the board for the whole data set. But for some clients, Cyber Monday's bigger. But that's usually because people like Nick Flynt and the retention team are crushing the game and driving those Cyber Monday sales. It's a really easy day to overspend. And then you're just handing your margin on a silver platter back to Google, which you do not want to do.
Brett Curry (06:28):
And so yeah, really important. I think that's something that I would challenge you, listener, to get right is spend the right level throughout those cyber days so that you're not missing opportunities, but so that you're also not destroying your margin. Great. Well, I just was talking about you, Nick, and how your efforts or the efforts of the retention team really drive Cyber Monday results, but it's important for that whole during period for peak holiday. What are you doing and what are your tips for email SMS and all things retention?
Nick Flint (06:59):
I thought of a couple of the different brands that we manage and how they fall into different buckets here. So I wanted to have tips that varied across the board so that way anyone listening to this can get something applicable for their own brand. So if you're a one and done purchase type brand, really leaning into the gifting angle, like if you sell desks, maybe even mattresses, super nice knife sets, things like that where you only need to purchase one, split off your past purchasers and say, Hey, you got yours, you love it, you know how good it is. It makes the perfect gift this year. Your non-purchasers get them to buy yours first and make them fall in love with it. But on the other end, if you have a super high repurchasable skew count, think supplements, apparel, maybe nail polish, we've been using more and more dynamic blocks in all of our emails.
Nick Flint (07:47):
So it's showing them the products that they were looking at and we'll add in that FOMO and that urgency down to the last few of these, hey look, it's all the products that you wanted. The customer doesn't know that it's customized to them or almost about to sell out of these or down to the last few things like that and then show them the products that they were looking at. That has been a huge uptick versus just a generic static image in there showing off some products.
Brett Curry (08:12):
Love that. Love that. Good. And what does it look like in terms of frequency of sends or mix of sends between email and SMS? I will say, just tip the hat, I know they get a lot of air time on other podcasts, but Marsman, I saw an ad on Meta, clicked on, I kind of went to the site. And actually it sounded good on the email and SMS list because I wanted to watch. It's brilliant, man. I've had to really restrain myself to keep from purchasing. I probably will to try it out, but I get so many emails and SMS messages from them, but they don't seem overly intrusive. And I haven't responded, so actually I don't think I've got anything today. I did for several days. But what does that look like in terms of frequency, mix? How are we doing that during peak?
Nick Flint (08:59):
In the nicest way possible, we're hammering people. This is the chance to buy it. We're contacting them daily for email SMS, sometimes even twice daily. But to make it not obtrusive and not annoying and to not make them unsubscribe, we make sure that each touchpoint has a unique reason for coming across. So over that five-day stretch, if we have 10 campaigns going out, each one has a very unique value prop to it and unique angle that we're coming from. So it's not just sales here, sales here, sales here, sales here. It's sales here. Hey, here's how you can save more. Order by midnight for free shipping, and then these best sellers are almost out of stock. Four unique angles so it doesn't feel like you got the same thing over and over.
Brett Curry (09:42):
Yeah. And the realization I got, again, watching Marsmen and what they do, two thoughts that I had. One, most of our clients, most brands don't email or send SMS messages enough, especially during that window when someone's really interested. Because guess what percentage of my day I was thinking about Marsman? Zero, unless I got a message from them. And so in between the messages, I wouldn't think about them at all, but they had to keep sending me more messages. But they were all unique and they were all creative and some of them were kind of fun, some of them were just informational, some of them were really getting me to purchase. But yeah, I think we all probably underdo it instead of overdoing it when it comes to email and SMS. All right, great. Let's shift to Amazon here, some kind of rapid fire in the moment, in game, what adjustments do we have?
Brett Curry (10:28):
And then we're going to go back to Google for post and wrap up. So go ahead, Trenton.
Trenton Bodenbach (10:34):
Yeah. One of my favorite quotes, so my wife, I use this in every area of my life is no plan survives first contact. As a parent, no matter what I plan for, it's not what's going to happen.
Brett Curry (10:45):
What was Mike Tyson's quote, everyone has a plan until they get punched in the face?
Trenton Bodenbach (10:47):
Until you get punched in the face. And do you know what? Sometimes Amazon can be a punch in the face. And so we talked on the last episode about, hey, using big deal days to forecast to help you get inventory, all of this. But you know what? Sometimes you get it right and then sometimes an influencer tweets and all of a sudden your products blow up and you didn't expect it and you start selling through. So the biggest advice -
Brett Curry (11:09):
Good problem to have, still a problem.
Trenton Bodenbach (11:10):
Yeah, it's great. But also then you're maybe running a big discount and then you're realizing you're going to run out of inventory on that product. That's your top product and you still have a lot of days post Cyber five or whenever that happens. So the biggest thing I can say is tracking. Tracking during and looking at that information that's coming in. Hey, what's my sale velocity? How much inventory do I have in Amazon? What am I doing elsewhere? And then adjusting accordingly. You know how many clients we've ended coupons early or turned off because we're like, hey, we're going to stock out.
Brett Curry (11:45):
We're going to sell out. Save your margin.
Trenton Bodenbach (11:48):
Focus on profitability. And we've made way more money than if we would've not. And you don't know that. And sometimes a lot of owners, they're doing a lot of this themselves. They're running multiple platforms or they're even maybe running one platform themselves and using agencies or you're juggling a lot. So I know it's a big ask to be looking at numbers and all these different platforms and every day, but it's crucial, especially when you're running big discounts on your products and especially if you're a giftable item and where a lot of your profitability is coming is, and we just kind of talked about this, within this small stretch of time compared to the full year, don't be afraid to change the plan. And that plan a lot of times is either lowering a discount -
Brett Curry (12:33):
Pulling audible.
Trenton Bodenbach (12:34):
Getting rid of a coupon or maybe just finding that product. And again, 20% of our products for our clients represent 67% of their sales in a year. So that 20% of those products you pay attention to and really be able to be willing to adjust accordingly.
Brett Curry (12:52):
Make or break a year for sure. More on Amazon, one second. Bill is out there doing things, making stuff happen, meeting with clients. He's got to go early. But before you go, Bill, one last thought on that after period. So after the Cyber five/Cyber 12, what's your tip for that time period?
Bill Cover (13:12):
Yeah, so 40% of your Q4 revenue, according to our data that we pulled, is going to happen in that period after Cyber Monday. So that's significant. So I would say stay strong through your last shipping day. One thing to consider as well is do you want to run a boxing day promo? Do you have some reason to keep running media in that back half of December because you're going to get that media at a discount while everyone else is pulling back. In our data, pulling all of our Google Ads data, we had some of our highest ROAS in the period that was December 26th through December 31st. That might be a great excuse to run some type of promo. Now, that ROAS is high because people are getting gift cards for Christmas and we're pulling back on budgets and spend and that stuff. So that combination is going to -
Brett Curry (14:07):
Click cost goes down, less competition. Everything's kind of working in your favor for that ROAS to be high, but it's a period a lot of people ignore and they shouldn't.
Bill Cover (14:14):
Yeah, exactly. And so if you think you could run some kind of promo during that boxing day period, I think it will go well for you. I would definitely plan ahead, have a plan in place probably before mid-December and understand what you're going to do with your budgets and what this promo is and all that stuff. But yeah, I think it would be a great thing to test.
Brett Curry (14:36):
I love it. All right, Bill, appreciate it. Go take care of clients.
Bill Cover (14:40):
Thank you, Brett.
Brett Curry (14:41):
So absolutely really important that we think about that post window. Hey, thanks again for tuning in. This episode's brought to you by OMG Commerce. That's my agency. Hey, we're specialists at creating omnichannel growth for brands profitably. Now the greatest brands we know are no longer just D2C. Yes, they're masters of D2C, but they're also growing and scaling on marketplaces and in retail stores. And we understand the complexities of how to grow in all of those channels from a campaign strategy, a creative strategy, and a measurement strategy. In fact, we recently won a Google Agency Excellence Award for helping Arctic Coolers grow their retail sales in Walmart using YouTube. We've helped add almost eight figures in growth on Amazon for brands, and we've even helped a brand go from nine to 10 figures. And so we want to help you grow. So if you're not satisfied with your growth in any of those channels or you're looking to unlock new growth, we should probably chat.
Brett Curry (15:47):
Visit us at omgcommerce.com, click that let's talk button. We love to schedule a strategy session with you. With that, back to the show. So post Cyber five for sure, like I mentioned at the top of the show, a few of the biggest days of the year in terms of total dollar spent, depending on category and things like that, actually happened after the CyberFive. Now almost all of the e-commerce revenue, like Cyber five or the biggest or Black Friday Cyber Money are the biggest. But for retail stores, there's a few days after that are just as big or bigger. So keep that in mind for sure. I'm going to show you a couple other stats here to kind of make this clear and drive this home. Let's talk about YouTube one more time. So again, YouTube kind of during. Basically our clients who are YouTube forward, YouTube focused more than the average brand, they're slashing their YouTube budgets, relatively speaking, from about 40% of their total mix across all Google down to 23%.
Brett Curry (16:47):
So what is that, like a 45% or more drop? Cyber five, we're harvesting, we're closing deals, people are shopping. We don't go quiet on YouTube and demand gen, but we don't want to overspend there. But then after the cyber five, you got that final push, that final window before your shipping cutoff day, lean into it a little bit more. But those two weeks are really the lowest weeks for performance or the lowest periods I should say for spend for YouTube and demand gen. However, the ROAS and platform ROAS for YouTube, take it with a grain of salt. If you're leaning into YouTube, you know you got to look at things like post-purchase survey and incrementality tests and whatnot. What YouTube says about itself and platform, it's going to under count big time, but still you see, relatively speaking, huge increase. So October is when we're planting the seeds, then week leading up to Cyber five, Cyber five and post is when we're harvesting, and that's when we see that ROAS really jump up across YouTube.
Brett Curry (17:48):
And yeah, we see other days really here where click costs do go up, so that's where you got to watch it. And another reason why Cyber Monday may be a little less profitable, clicks go way up then, very competitive. But yeah, that post period, so thinking through also what is your promo that you're going to have for the days after the Cyber five? And to Trent's point, yeah, be flexible. Have a plan, but also have a backup plan and depending on which way you need to go. Do I need to give more of a discount because actually sales, we're turning behind. We have less of a discount because we're going to sell out or because things are just going really, really well, let's maximize profits. Understand and then get those early reads and pivot because after the Cyber five, you still have time to make hay and so lean into that.
Brett Curry (18:44):
Nick Flynt, what about you? What about for after peak holiday? What are we doing on the email and SMS side?
Nick Flint (18:49):
We've got a four-step plan for them after their Black Friday is going down. So first, I love this one, especially as the world shifts into more and more AI type stuff and you're just like, what's even real anymore? I love a BTS picture. We're going to snap your team in the warehouse. You're going to show those orders going out. You're going to show you as the owner with a thumbs up packaging up orders.
Brett Curry (19:12):
BTS behind the scenes.
Nick Flint (19:13):
Behind the
Brett Curry (19:13):
Scenes.
Nick Flint (19:13):
Just to clarify for
Brett Curry (19:14):
Those. Yeah, yeah.
Nick Flint (19:15):
Exactly. So bring that realness to them. And I love this as an SMS strategy too, because I would text a friend a picture. So instead of your nice little gift, image, mock-up that you're sending out as a text, just make it broad behind the scenes. Say, Black Friday was insane. If you got in on this, congrats. We're packaging up all these. Expect to have them out the door tomorrow.
Brett Curry (19:35):
Yeah. Yeah. Love that. And you can even throw in a message like, "Hey, we're in the warehouse. It's all hands on deck. Look at us shipping stuff out. Not too late for you if you missed it." Or it's like, "Hey, your stuff is on the way if they did order." But I love that. And when I get texts from brands that are just stale, feels like AI, it's only a discount, maybe I'll pay attention to a few of those. But when you mix that in with some fun stuff and I see behind the scenes, and maybe it's the founder in the warehouse or something like that, if the founder is public facing, it's pretty cool. And it endears me to that brand and certainly drives more purchases.
Nick Flint (20:12):
Exactly. And then with those orders that you're shipping out in your warehouse, I'm pushing so many of our brands to do this strategy this year is getting some kind of insert into the package.
Brett Curry (20:22):
Yes.
Nick Flint (20:22):
The simple version is just a printed out piece of paper, a nice little cardboard one, offering them a discount on their next order or offering them something for that next step. Or if you want to go big, you can get mock-up plastic gift cards made so that when they unbox it, they have that gift card. So you had this huge holiday peak as all of those orders start showing up, you're going to get that second little wave of sales coming in because you just tossed a couple of inserts in the packages.
Brett Curry (20:47):
Yeah. Depending on when you're listening to this, you're like, oh shoot, I've got no time to go to a printer. I can't get a fancy card or something like that. Print a piece of paper, right? Super easy. You do it yourself or go to FedEx office or whatever. Just get it done because everybody's going to see that and make good use of that. That's another strategy that a lot of people just are not using enough. So lean into that. Love it.
Nick Flint (21:11):
Last two here. You got two different audiences, those who bought and those who decided not to buy. So those who bought, I like to reaffirm that they made such a good decision to purchase during this period because now you're training them in the future when you have these big sales to go ahead and buy because you reaffirmed that. So I would say, "Hey, congrats on buying during this period. You got our best offer of the year. You're going to love X when it shows up." So now as a consumer, I'm getting a little pat on the back like, "Hey, I did a good job."
Brett Curry (21:39):
But you're feeling good. You feel good about yourself. And hey, we all could potentially have a little bit of buyer's remorse after we make a decision. If you're buying a gift for somebody else, probably not. But either way, that message saying, "Good choice, good on you. You made the right call." It's a great message to receive. I love it.
Nick Flint (21:57):
Oxytocin, serotonin, melatonin, all of that stuff's getting released when I get that text from the owner.
Brett Curry (22:02):
It's just happening. It's a happy cocktail of chemicals for sure. And then for those that did not buy.
Nick Flint (22:09):
Those who didn't buy, shame on them for not giving you their money. But this is your chance to win them over one last time. You can go with the typical sale extended or you can escalate the offer. You obviously don't want any purchasers to get this escalated offer. You could switch it up a little bit. So if you're running 25% off site wide, maybe you offer 40 bucks off over a $100 order. If they get to that 150, it's basically the same thing, but throw one last little spaghetti noodle at the wall. See if you can get the stick, see if you can get them to place that order in case they missed it.
Brett Curry (22:41):
Love it. Love it. Throw that final pass, take that final shot, do it. You're not going to see anything if you don't try, so more shots on goal for sure. Just makes three sports metaphors in there all in one. So I knew Trent would be proud of that. Trent, on the Amazon side, what are we doing after, we'll call it Turkey 12 because I think that's maybe what Amazon has called it most recently, but what are we doing during that after period?
Trenton Bodenbach (23:10):
Well, email and SMS has a four step, but we have a five... No, I'm just kidding. Five steps for you today.
Brett Curry (23:17):
A little gamesmanship. I like this.
Trenton Bodenbach (23:20):
Then I'm going to throw in probably seven sports metaphors here for you. Actually, to be very honest, my main advice, and this is just unique to Amazon because we see this a lot also when somebody comes to us and we're looking, let's say we sign them, we are doing all their advertising, they're not using a third party at any tools or to run their Amazon, they're just using Seller Central. We have this issue where when we go to look at historical data, Amazon is terrible at giving you that because it all is just lumped into just this giant chunk. If I want to see what happened on Cyber five, I can only see what happened in November. I can only see what we spent. I can't look at a day or a chunk. It's just all just lumped into a month. And that really puts us at a kind of disadvantage for understanding what you did, unless sellers have a very clear, "Oh, we did this, here's all the data." But a lot of the times they're so busy, they're like, "I don't remember what we ran.
Trenton Bodenbach (24:16):
I don't remember what we did. Here's just the big picture." And so what I would very much encourage you to do is once we get past it, and I know you got a lot going on during Cyber five, a lot going on, but somebody on your team, if it's not you, start pulling that information either on a daily basis and just throw it in a folder. It could be in Drive, it can be a cloud folder, it can be a ChatGPT folder, project. Start pulling that information and you don't even have to be looking at it on a day-to-day basis, but what you can do is then you have all that data. So if it's not you, it's an agency, it's somebody can then take it, really put it together in a comprehensive way and say, "Hey, what did we do last year? Oh, hey, here's what sales look like.
Trenton Bodenbach (24:57):
Here's our discount. Here's everything that we know." And we have the information. Because if we don't have that for going into 2027 next year, you're going to be kind of flying blind again where you're like, "I don't remember what I discounted. I don't remember profit margins." And I know I'm talking to a lot of smart business owners, but the issue is sometimes it's not, it's just time. And so take the moment, pull the information, and then that way you're setting yourself up for success for the next year because it's really important you have a good understanding of what you did, and that will really inform you what to do in the following, even Prime Day, following big deal today, following Cyber five.
Brett Curry (25:33):
Can't make good decisions without good data. Never been easier to process good data, but you got to get it. Amazon doesn't make it that easy, so take matters into your own hands, get that done.
Trenton Bodenbach (25:43):
Yeah. And I would encourage you also, man, AI tools are getting so good, especially when it comes to correlating and finding and processing data, large amounts of data. So if you pull that information on a daily basis, I know it seems insane, but now you don't have to put that into a spreadsheet yourself. You can literally have that all as source data in Claude and just say, "Hey, give me all this information based on the 60 days that I'm looking at." And it'll take a minute and it'll output it and you'll have it.
Brett Curry (26:12):
Totally. Cool. What else are we doing after the Cyber five? Because hey, Amazon has fast shipping, so maybe when your shipping cutoff is done for your dot-com, it's probably still going on Amazon. So a lot of big days after the Turkey 12, the Cyber five. What else are we doing on Amazon to maximize?
Trenton Bodenbach (26:34):
I would follow up kind of what Bill and you talked about at the beginning of, man,
Brett Curry (26:39):
A
Trenton Bodenbach (26:39):
Lot of people will get Amazon gift cards for Christmas. A lot of people will be getting a gift that they honestly don't want, and they're going to return and they're going to have a credit on Amazon for Christmas. So thinking through a strategy, again, if you have a giftable item, a lot of... I mean, honestly, for me, when I do a return, I then buy something practical for my house. So if you have a practical item at that point, a lot of people just will do returns
Brett Curry (27:05):
And a
Trenton Bodenbach (27:05):
Lot of that spin will happen post-Christmas. So looking at -
Brett Curry (27:08):
Yep. I'm returning the socks and then I'm just going to buy coffee.
Trenton Bodenbach (27:10):
Yeah, I'll buy coffee or I'm going to buy coffee filters, things I need every month that I'm like, I'm just buy it with my credit. And so this is advice for honesty, consumable and practical items as well is be thinking through, okay, do you know what? As we get into the latter half of December, the beginning of January, how can I better position myself to make sure that I'm being seen by my repeat customers? And so whether utilizing email and SMS and saying, "Hey, you know what? We're running a great deal on Amazon and that post-Christmas hangover, you need good coffee, hey -
Brett Curry (27:46):
Shipping is over on the website with last day ship has passed, but you can still get it on Amazon. Yep.
Trenton Bodenbach (27:51):
Yeah. So just utilizing portions of... A lot of people also, we talked about how Amazon's a demand capture, a lot of people will not go to a D2C site to purchase. And so utilizing some of those audiences to say," Hey, you know what? We're still shipping. You can still get this on time for Christmas or even if you have a practical item, hey, a lot of times we're hosting for Christmas and hosting for New Year's, New Year's Eve, New Year's Day. So thinking through, "Hey, how do I creatively get in front of my audience and utilizing those for those later ship days?"
Brett Curry (28:29):
Love that. And I really believe, just like we talked about in the last episode, leading up to peak holiday, we're leaning into Meta, we're leaning into YouTube, we're leaning into top of funnel. We're maybe just keeping our sponsored product ads, our sponsored brand ads consistent. We don't want to disappear there. We don't want to overspend. We want to keep some good guardrails there as far as ROAS goes or a cost goes. As we get into the Cyber five then in that period after, that's maybe when we are leaning in a little bit more to our non-brand sponsored product ads and our sponsored brand video. Both of those are really good at reaching net new. Obviously, you got to watch the return because if you are priced way higher than your competitors on Amazon or whatever, if it's someone that's never heard of you, never seen you, they don't know you, you just got to watch it.
Brett Curry (29:13):
But those are the times to lean in to those more bottom of funnel ad channels. Any advice there on the ad side of things? CPCs really spike. We see that on Google, Black Friday, especially Cyber Monday, CPCs go through the roof, but return goes through the roof as well, but you got to watch that. Any advertising tips for the post window?
Trenton Bodenbach (29:34):
It really depends on your product margin or sorry, your products that you're selling. Again, giftable items, you're going to pull back when that shipping window closes, but then again, you're going to watch that and then those cost per clicks will go down. When we hit December 20, 21, 22 on, they're going to drop off, but then they're going to spike again post. So two things. One, depends what audience I'm talking to. If you're an owner of a consumable item, this is going to look different for you than a giftable item. A giftable item, I'm pulling hard back on the 20th on. Whenever Amazon says we cannot ship anymore, I'm going to be watching my... Whether you're looking at OAS, ACOS, whatever KPI you're judging years off.
Brett Curry (30:21):
20th, man, Amazon's shipping through the 23rd in a lot of cases. 24th, depending on what it is and where you are.
Trenton Bodenbach (30:26):
They see that sometimes and then they're like, "I'm not delivering it for seven days." You told me you sold me a bill of goods here. But I would say this is just watch that ROAS, and then begin to begin to feather that down, that spin down. But if you have a consumable, also be watching it because if that CPC is going down cost per click and you have a good chance of like, "Hey, you know what? My competitors were ranking at this. Everybody's pulling back. Let's test pushing. Let's see what happens here." But as a whole, it's such a good time to test for certain products because you're coming into January 1st. As soon as we get into January 1st, we're talking new year, new mean. We're looking at a lot of people who have those Amazon gift cards.
Brett Curry (31:10):
Supplements nutrition, exercise, all that just goes through the roof.
Trenton Bodenbach (31:13):
Yeah. And that's when we're talking like, okay, it's game time for certain subsects and certain verticals. So I would say pull back if you're a giftable item when we start to hit those limits on Prime Day shipping and then also start pushing. Honestly, if you're a supplement, I would be thinking real hard on pushing extremely hard from that 2021 on.
Brett Curry (31:36):
Yeah, that's great. Nick Flint, any final tips for the post Cyber Five and beyond? Any final tips or words of wisdom?
Nick Flint (31:48):
I like to compare my thoughts, strategy and projections beforehand to how it actually played out in the future because afterwards you're like, "Oh, I knew we should have made the discount higher and the sales were this."
Brett Curry (32:01):
Kind of a what do we get right, what do we get wrong type of thing.
Nick Flint (32:04):
Love that. But you're looking at it from the backend without having that forward projections. So I like to actually write it out beforehand. Hey, for this brand, we're running this discount for these reasons over these days with this strategy, and I think it will do this. So that way I don't have the bias of how the sale actually did at the end. Afterwards, I'll go through and compare it and be like, "Hey, I did this period, but sales are still strong on that third day, so maybe we should add a third, fourth, fifth day afterwards."
Brett Curry (32:31):
It's so good. Yeah, going into it. And because it's just another way to learn and to get smarter, better for next time, document, here's what we're doing, here's why, here are our expectations so that you can then measure against that. And again, AI is going to make that way easier than it ever was before we need to do stuff manually, but what a great way to learn where were we wrong and why were we wrong? Because now we can get smarter and better for the next go round. Love it. Well, you may be listening and thinking, "Man, I need some guys like that helping me with my Amazon or Google or YouTube or retention." And so reach out to OMG Commerce. We'd love to talk to you either before the holidays or if it's too late, we're listening to this. Hey, let's chat afterwards. Things are going to go according to plan.
Brett Curry (33:17):
Let us help you fix that. We'd love to work with you. We love working with great brands. And so with that, until next time, thank you for listening. That'll do it for this week's episode. One final mention, if you feel like you've stalled out with your growth, if you feel like you've missed opportunities, and if you feel like your current team or agency, they just don't have that buyer anymore, or maybe you feel like you've outgrown them, we would love to chat. You may be missing opportunities and we don't want to miss an opportunity to work with great brands. So if you'd love to scale on YouTube or Google or Meta or Amazon or email and SMS, or just like a second set of eyes to look over how you're growing right now, visit us at omgcommerce.com and we can't wait to help you scale profitably.


.jpg)
.png)
